Glee Fans Hope to See Lea Michele and Mark Salling Live Happily Ever After as Rachel and Puck

It's been a tumultuous few months in the love life of a Glee diva Rachel Berry (Lea Michele), including a tearful breakup with on-again, off-again boyfriend Finn (Cory Monteith) on the November 30 episode. Having watched Rachel struggle to find true love, Broadway.com asked readers to play matchmaker—and our poll drew the largest voter turnout of the year! In a surprise finish, sexy bad boy Puck (Mark Salling) came in first place, with a whopping 59% of votes. (Puck and Rachel have canoodled before and found themselves in each other's arms yet again, bonding over their shared Jewish heritage.)

Second place goes to Finn (Cory Monteith) with 34% of votes. Rachel removed her "Finn" necklace and emptied her locker of romantic memorabilia after learning of his past dalliance with Santana (Naya Rivera). However, our Miss Berry soon realized her mistake and asked for a second chance, which was nixed by her makeout session with Puck. Who knows what the future holds for this duo?

Trailing in third place is last season's guest star (and Michele's former Spring Awakening co-star and real life BFF) Jonathan Groff, who wooed Rachel as Vocal Adrenaline hottie Jessie St. James. Groff scored 4% of votes.

Thanks for voting!