V-Day Flashback! A Pre-Glee Lea Michele on Her First Kiss, Tighty Whities, Jonathan Taylor Thomas & More!

Emmy nominee Lea Michele's current TV love life may find the Glee star hoping to reconnect with high school football star Finn (Cory Monteith), but Broadway fans will always remember her onstage romantic struggles as Wendla from the Tony-winning musical Spring Awakening. Back on Valentine's Day 2008, during the musical's acclaimed Broadway run, Michele joined her Spring Awakening co-stars (including Glee veteran Jonathan Groff) at Broadway.com's studio to dish about their own personal love lives. Michele spilled intimate details about her first kiss, bad first dates and much more. Take a look at what she had to say below!