Fans Want Lea Michele to Get Wicked On Glee With 'I'm Not That Girl'

With Lea Michele tackling Rent's "Take Me or Leave Me," another song from Tony winner—and Michele's onscreen birth mother—Idina Menzel on Glee, Broadway.com asked which other song from Menzel's extensive catalog you'd like to hear Michele take on next. The votes are in fans hope Michele will channel Wicked's Elphaba again (she performed "Defying Gravity" last season) by singing "I'm Not That Girl." Twenty-four percent of fans voted for the Stephen Schwartz-penned song. 

Readers also hope to see Michele let loose and have fun with The Wild Party's "The Life of the Party." Fifteen percent of readers voted for the song which appeared in the 2000 off-Broadway Andrew Lippa musical.

Third place resulted in a tie between Wicked's "The Wizard and I" and Aida's "My Strongest Suit." Both songs earned 12% of votes.

Thanks for voting!