Darren Criss may be the newest inductee into the brotherhood of man, but he’s also the member of another important group: Team StarKid. The Glee star co-founded the theater troupe in 2009 with classmates at the University of Michigan’s School of Music, Theatre and Dance. Team StarKid is best known for their production of A Very Potter Musical, a parody of the hit Harry Potter films (and How to Succeed original star Daniel Radcliffe!). On January 7, current members of the Chicago-based group traveled to New York to cheer on teammate Criss in How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying and check out his moves as J. Pierrepont Finch. Click on to see photos of this happy reunion, then head to the Al Hirschfeld Theatre to see Criss’ Broadway debut as Finch in this limited engagement, ending January 22.