Rory O’Malley has audiences rolling in the aisles as the gay, tap-dancing Mormon Elder McKinley in the Broadway hit The Book of Mormon. The Tony nominated actor invited Broadway.com into his dressing room at the Eugene O’Neill Theatre for even more laughs. O’Malley keeps himself smiling with a photo of himself in high school with fellow Broadway star Audra McDonald, a program from his cousin’s play in which he gets a shout-out and a bobble head of the South Park character Butters. He also showed us the most unique gift he got from a fan—a dance body bag. Not familiar? Well click below because it’s something you have to see to believe…and get your tickets today to see O’Malley in The Book of Mormon.