It was a dazzling affair at the NYU Skirball Center on May 6, when starry presenters, nominees and guests united to honor the best of off-Broadway at the 2012 Lucille Lortel Awards. Hosted by Mario Cantone, the ceremony included presentations and performances by Laura Benanti, Steve Kazee, Christian Borle, Michael Cerveris, Hugh Dancy, Cristin Milioti, Alexis Bledel, Sarah Paulson and more. Once took home the award for Outstanding Musical, Outstanding Play went to Sons of the Prophet, and Adam Driver (Look Back in Anger), Tonya Pinkins (Milk Like Sugar), Santino Fontana (Sons of the Prophet) and Sanaa Lathan (By the Way, Meet Vera Stark) were honored for their outstanding performances. Click here for a complete list of winners, then check out our gallery of photos from the big night!