From songs by Darren Criss to impromptu speeches by Stephanie J. Block, the 13th annual Broadway.com Audience Choice Awards were a ridiculously good time, but when the show was done, the fun was far from over! Criss and the evening’s many stars kept the good times going at the after party, where they made sure to stop by the official Broadway.com photo booth. Of course, there was a handy table packed with Broadway show-themed props on hand, and the actors couldn’t resist playing dress-up. Peter and the Starcatcher’s Celia Keenan-Bolger and Adam Chanler-Berat hammed it up, Newsies star Jeremy Jordan got smooches from two lovely leading ladies and Spider-Man got kisses from…just about everybody. Click on to see these stars and many more, captured by Jenny Anderson in their photo booth finest.