Diehard fans of Broadway vet Aaron Tveit no doubt tuned in to watch the Graceland star sit in the hot seat with Andy Cohen on Bravo’s Watch What Happens Live. Joining fellow guest Ethan Hawke, Tveit got down to business with all of Cohen’s typically off-kilter interview games including “Outside the Actor’s Studio” (in which Tveit revealed his first celebrity crush), “Teach Me Your Talent” (in which Tveit reprised his one-handed clap) and “Tveit Ball of Fire” (in which Tveit demonstrated a tongue-tied approach to horror movies). Watch the clips of the great Tveit below!