Summer is over, and you know what that means—it’s time for a whole new crop of Broadway shows to open! Screen stars galore are trying the Great White Way on for size: Ewan McGregor is wooing Maggie Gyllenhaal in The Real Thing, Kieran Culkin and Michael Cera are scoring some drugs in This Is Our Youth and Rupert Grint is trying his hand at directing (on stage, at least) in It’s Only a Play, just to name a few. Screen stars are making their Broadway debuts tried and true hit shows, too—Emma Stone is coming to the Cabaret, Keke Palmer and Sherri Shepherd are joining the Cinderella kingdom and more. So, we’ve gotta know: Which star’s Broadway debut are you the most excited to see? Cast your vote below!