The Broadway.com Culturalist Challenge! Rank the Top Broadway Star Turns on American Horror Story

The Broadway.com staff is hooked on Culturalist, the super-fun website that has become the hot spot for top ten lists. In fact, we love it so much that we decided to partner with them! Every week, we'll challenge you with a Broadway-themed topic and have you head over to Culturalist.com to rank your favorites. Then, we'll announce the most popular ten choices on The Broadway.com Show every Wednesday!

For our first challenge, we're asking you to consider all of the Broadway stars who have had the chance to show their dark sides on the first three seasons of the FX anthology hit American Horror Story. As we prepare to head to season four's Freak Show, we want you to pick your top ten Broadway star turns from seasons past. To kick it off, Editor-in-Chief Paul Wontorek has chosen his list right here. Do you agree? Passionately disagree? Make your own! Here's how:

STEP 1 - SELECT: Visit Culturalist to see all of your options. Highlight your ten favorites and click the continue button.

STEP 2 - RANK: Reorder your ten choices by dragging them into the correct spot on your list. Click the continue button.

STEP 3 - PREVIEW: You will now see your complete top ten list. If you like it, click the publish button. (If you don't have a Culturalist account, you'll be asked to create one or sign in with Facebook at this point.)

Once your list is published, you can see the overall rankings of everyone on the aggregate list. 

Have fun! And look for the results on the October 8 episode of The Broadway.com Show.