Finding Neverland headliner Matthew Morrison paid a visit to The Tonight Show on April 2, and Jimmy Fallon had quite the #TBT for him. Apparently, during Morrison’s college days at NYU, Matty Fresh starred in a dance instructional video (available on VHS!) titled Simply Funk. It’s just as absurd as it sounds. Unfortunately, those days are long gone, and the funky fresh moves now come with a price. While prepping for the new musical, Morrison encouraged the creators to give him plenty of demanding choreography and movement. “I was using my big boy voice,” he explained. “In my head, I was 26 years old.” The result? Lots of ice baths and heating pads. You can catch the bruised up Matty Fresh at the Lunt Fontanne Theatre, where Finding Neverland opens officially on April 15.