Spring Awakening's Austin P. McKenzie and Daniel Durant, Tuck Everlasting newcomer Sarah Charles Lewis and On Your Feet!'s Ana Villafañe were among the winners of the 72nd annual Theatre World Awards, which celebrate outstanding Broadway and off-Broadway debut performances. Bernadette Peters received the John Willis Award for Lifetime Achievement, and She Loves Me’s Nicholas Barasch earned the Dorothy Loudon Award for Excellence. The winners were honored at a ceremony at the Circle in the Square Theatre on May 23. Click through our gallery to enter the winners' circle!