Before Sutton Foster returns to the New York stage in off-Broadway's already twice-extended Sweet Charity, this brass band has got some furry shoes to fill. The two-time Tony winner stopped by The Late Show with Stephen Colbert on September 27 to sit down with the late night host and give Andrew Lloyd Webber's Tony-touting classic Cats a very, erm, realistic spin. "Look how much I threw up while you were at work!" Foster proudly belts, decked out in full feline fashion. Watch the hilarity ensue below and catch Foster in Sweet Charity beginning on November 2!