The Fans Have Spoken! Here's Which Broadway Stars Should Release a Holiday Album

Thanksgiving is officially over (but we won't judge you if you keep watching the Falsettos cast celebrate it again and again). This means we can all put those holiday carols on blast—Hamilton Tony winner Leslie Odom Jr and Broadway bombshell Megan Hilty's new Yuletide albums are already on repeat! In honor of the Christmas season's official start, we asked you to rank which Broadway stars should join faves like Idina Menzel, Kristin Chenoweth, Barbra Streisand and release a holiday album. Here are the top 10 Main Stem faves whose Christmas records would be at the top of your wishlists!


Cynthia Erivo


Laura Benanti


Darren Criss


Renée Elise Goldsberry


Sutton Foster 


Sierra Boggess


Audra McDonald


Laura Osnes


Lin-Manuel Miranda


Aaron Tveit