It has been nearly 50 years since Finian's Rainbow , the classic musical packed with jazz and American songbook standards, was last seen on a Broadway stage. On October 29 the tuner officially returned, bringing the story of Irishman Finian, his daughter Sharon, a stolen pot of gold and the topsy-turvy land of Missitucky back for audiences—including WOM panelists Maggie, Tom and Ellen—to see. While the talent of stars Cheyenne Jackson, Kate Baldwin, Jim Norton, Christopher Fitzgerald and more couldn't be denied, the show itself split the panel. Will Finian's Rainbow will have Irish eyes smiling? Watch the video to see the full review for yourself.