As Mormon missionaries in the Tony-nominated musical The Book of Mormon, Andrew Rannells and Josh Gad are used to going door to door to greet strangers, but on May 17, Mormon fans came to them to celebrate the show's newly released original cast recording. Gad and Rannells joined co-stars (and fellow Tony nominees) Rory O'Malley and Nikki M. James along with the rest of the Mormon cast onstage at the Eugene O'Neill Theatre to dish out autographs for the excited fans. Broadway.com was on the scene to snap some shots of the talented crew. Take a look below! The Book of Mormon cast recording is now available for digital download and hits stores June 7, be sure to purchase a copy of your own.