A surprising love triangle is happening at the St. James Theatre, where director Michael Mayer’s reimagined On a Clear Day You Can See Forever officially opened on December 11. Word of Mouth panelists Mariene, Peter and Tara Ann traveled back in time with stars Harry Connick Jr., Jessie Mueller and David Turner to watch the drama and hijinks unravel. Were they hypnotized by this reincarnation of the Lerner and Lane classic? Click below to find out.