Stephen Schwartz's Godspell has returned to Broadway for the first time in 40 years, but will audiences accept Jesus and his followers with arms wide open? Broadway.com sent our Word of Mouth reviewers Bennie, John and Kimberly to Circle in the Square Theatre, where Hunter Parrish and his co-stars are belting out popular tunes such as "Day By Day," "We Beseech Thee" and "All For the Best" and bringing plenty of modern twists to the classic show. Did this new production of Godspell make these audience members shout "Hallelujah"? Click below to find out!