Weekend Poll: Which Witch? Celebrate Wicked's Birthday by Picking Your Fave Elphaba!

With Wicked celebrating its seventh Broadway anniversary on October 30, we started to think about the many talented performers who have turned green and tried defying gravity as the musical's passionate, powerful and emerald-hued Elphaba. Over the course of the show's incredibly successful run, 11 different actresses have wowed audiences with their take on the Wicked witch. Sure all of them are "popular," but we want to know which Elphaba soars highest in your heart. From the show's orginal Tony-winning star Idina Menzel to current Elphaba Mandy Gonzalez, we've listed all the ladies who have claimed "I'm Not that Girl" on stage. Vote for your favorite below! (P.S. Happy Halloween!)