Which American Idol Hopeful Would Shine on Broadway? Vote Now!

Round 'em up: We've had Tamyra Gray (Bombay Dreams) and Fantasia Barrino (The Color Purple), Clay Aiken (Spamalot) and Taylor Hicks (Grease), Ace Young (Grease and Hair) and Diana DeGarmo (Hairspray and Hair). Heck, Constantine Maroulis even took it to the next level and scored a 2009 Tony Award nomination for Rock of Ages. It's no secret that American Idol has been fueling the Broadway casting pool for years now. With Season 9 of the hit TV talent search series officially down to its Top 10, which new hopeful do you think has the chops, charisma, stamina and overall performance prowess to next jump from the Idol stage to the Great White Way?

Take our poll to cast your vote!