Dr. Hook said it best: “Wanna see my smiling face on the cover of the Rolling Stone!” Well, the white-hot cast of TV’s Glee—including Broadway favorites Lea Michele and Matthew Morrison—made it, gracing the issue hitting newsstands on March 31. Accompanying Mark Seliger’s cheeky portrait (and the cover line “Glee Gone Wild”), the actors share personal tidbits and their own high school yearbook photos. Explaining the appeal of the show, creator Ryan Murphy notes, “It’s about there being great joy in being different, and great pain.” While awaiting the April 13 return of the show, check out the revealing Rolling Stone cover story, and savor the full magazine cover below.