Tom Stoppard's Arcadia has returned to Broadway for its first-ever revival. The production, directed by David Leveaux, stars Raul Esparza, Lia Williams, Margaret Colin, Tom Riley and Billy Crudup (who also starred in the original 1995 production). The century-swapping drama (the story unfolds both in the 19th century and present day) is filled with existential discussions, mathematical hypotheses, romantic entanglements and historical theories. Broadway.com sent our Word of Mouth panelists Jarrod, David and Jil to the show's home at the Ethel Barrymore Theatre to see what they thought of it all. Did they find the show epically entrancing or altogether too much? Take a look below for their opinions!