The May 17 episode of Glee found the students of McKinley High prepping for their big trip to New York City to compete at nationals. With only a week left, the singing teens needed to decide which glee club member would lead their group as a soloist. Only four members decided to audition for Mr. Schuester (Matthew Morrison) and new performance consultant Jesse St. James (guest star Jonathan Groff). Santana (Naya Rivera) opted to belt out a contemporary hit with Amy Winehouse's "Back to Black," while Mercedes (Amber Riley) took on the R&B classic "Try a Little Tenderness" and Kurt (Chris Colfer) and Rachel (Lea Michele) looked to Broadway standards "Some People" and "My Man," respectively. In the end, the group decided to band together instead of letting just one talent shine through. But we want to know: If the glee club had to pick one soloist to perform at nationals, who would you have chosen? Vote below!