The cast of Anything Goes, led by Tony-winning leading lady Sutton Foster, set forth on June 20 to take on a formidable task: capturing their tap-filled, high-energy show in a cast recording for Ghostlight Records. Broadway.com was on the scene at MSR Studios to get an inside look at the recording process and quiz Foster and co-stars Joel Grey, Colin Donnell, Adam Godley and Laura Osnes on just what it takes to make a great album. We chatted with these stars and more about their secrets for bringing classic Cole Porter songs to life offstage—and how, on studio day, some of them just can’t help feeling like serious rock stars.