The Book of Mormon star Josh Gad returned to his former stomping ground at The Daily Show with Jon Stewart on December 12 to appear in a hilarious seasonal sketch as founding father Benjamin Franklin. After learning The History Channel inaccurately reported a story about the history of Christmas, Stewart decided to travel back in time (via DeLorean, obviously!) to 1789 to discuss Franklin's (Gad) stance on celebrating the holiday. Check out Gad and Stewart spread holiday cheer in the clip below.