It’s been an ongoing joke with How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying star Darren Criss and his Broadway predecessor Daniel Radcliffe that the two had never gotten to meet, but according to both Finches, there has finally been a rendezvous. Radcliffe already dished about the duo’s first meeting, and now the Glee star shares his side of the story on VH1’s TheFabLife. Watch Darren chat about his first encounter with the “complete gentleman,” then meet Criss yourself at the Al Hirschfeld Theatre, where he plays J. Pierrepont Finch through January 22.