Andrew Rannells Chows Down on Baby Food on Watch What Happens Live!

Andrew Rannells plays a baby daddy on The New Normal, so it was only natural that the former Book of Mormon star should play a game of infant proportions (or, technically, portions) during his visit to Watch What Happens Live! Host Andy Cohen paired Rannells with Nicole Richie (who has two tots of her own) for a baby food-feeding frenzy—with Rannells, on the receiving end of some premium mush—to see if the Tony nominee could flavors of baby food while blindfolded. Watch the hilarious clip below!