It’s a four-ring circus on the January 2013 cover of Vanity Fair, featuring Grace star Paul Rudd and his hilarious This Is 40 co-stars Leslie Mann, Melissa McCarthy and Megan Fox. Rudd sports a royal blue jacket, a ruffled tuxedo shirt, bedazzled shoes and one heck of a mustache in the new issue—he hasn’t looked this stylish since Anchorman! In the new Knocked Up spin-off film by Judd Apatow, Rudd stars as Pete, a music exec and father of two coming to terms with turning the big 4-0 alongside his wife, Debbie (Mann). Check out this Hot Shot of Rudd and company in Vanity Fair, then pick up the new comedy issue on newsstands December 5!