Now that the Tony nominations have been announced, there are a ton of Broadway performers (some veterans, some newbies) who have reason to celebrate! We’re always happy to see new faces earn their first nod for theater’s most prestigious award, and this year is no exception, with a whopping 21 first-timers in the race. From acting veterans like Tom Hanks and Cicely Tyson to Broadway debuts like Bertie Carvel and Tom Sturridge, there is a slew of stars to think about when answering this week’s big question: Whose first-time nomination gets you the most excited? Cast your vote below!