Although he’s nowhere near as tightly wound as his character in Broadway’s First Date, Zachary Levi does share one thing with his character Aaron: a handful of dating disasters! While stopping by The Tonight Show with Jay Leno, Levi dished about the excitement of making his Broadway debut, his harrowing experience on a date at Disneyland and the reason why Chuck fans should be running to see First Date. Below, check out the clip of the impeccably dressed—and newly minted—Broadway star!