Professor X—uh, we mean Patrick Stewart—is currently starring in not one, but two plays at the Cort Theatre alongside his pal Ian McKellen: Waiting For Godot and No Man’s Land. Stewart stopped by The Daily Show on November 7 to catch up with Jon Stewart (a guy with a very familiar last name) about the inconsistencies of his lobster Halloween costume (which, if you haven’t seen it yet, is adorable), his mind-blowing theory about the secret identities of politicians, and of course, his two new Broadway shows in repertory. Click below for a clip!