Earlier this week, People magazine unveiled its annual Sexiest Man Alive issue with Maroon 5 frontman and The Voice judge Adam Levine taking the top honor. As you probably know, there are plenty of hot men currently seducing audiences on Broadway. From Mormon missionaries (Matt Doyle in The Book of Mormon) to emcees of Harlem's Cotton Club (Dulé Hill in After Midnight) and gentleman callers (Brian J. Smith in The Glass Menagerie), there's a man for all tastes on the Great White Way this season. A fierce battle was waged to determine who made our list of candidates—seriously, we have the cuts and bruises to prove it—but we think these 12 Broadway hunks deserve the title of sexiest. In honor of People's steamy new issue, we want to know: Who is Broadway's sexiest man alive in 2013? Vote below!