We know Mike Tyson is a Broadway fan—he brought his solo show, Undisputed Truth, to the Great White Way in 2012—but it was still a fun surprise to see him tapping his toes in the audience of Broadway’s After Midnight! The jazzy revue features Dule Hill, Tony nominee Adriane Lenox and special guest star Fantasia Barrino singing the songs of Duke Ellington alongside a company of talented singers and dancers. After the show, Tyson headed backstage to greet Barrino in her dressing room. Check out these snapshots of the former heavyweight champion’s visit, then head to the Brooks Atkinson Theatre to see After Midnight!