Anything can happen in New York City—you could even meet a Broadway star at the SoHo Apple Store! Broadway.com Editor-in-Chief Paul Wontorek moderated an If/Then chat on October 27 with Jackie Burns (the standby for headliner Idina Menzel), Broadway.com Audience Choice Award winner Anthony Rapp, director Michael Greif and composer Tom Kitt. After chatting about the new musical, Burns and Rapp sang a few of our favorite If/Then tunes, including “Learn to Live Without,” “You Don’t Need to Love Me” and “Some Other Me.” Check out these shots of the stars at the Apple Store, then see them live at the Richard Rodgers Theatre!