The Book of Mormon said goodbye to lovable Elders Ben Platt and Nic Rouleau on January 4—but wait, before you start sobbing uncontrollably, we have great news! Gavin Creel and Christopher John O’Neill are taking the reigns as Elder Price and Elder Cunningham, respectively, beginning January 6. Both of these guys are Mormon tour vets, so we already know we’re in great hands. On Twitter, Platt posted this adorable photo of the foursome getting dinner together before he and Rouleau pass the torch to the new guys. Check it out, then see O’Neill and Creel go to Orlando—err, Uganda—in The Book of Mormon on Broadway!