A duo of stage and screen favorites stopped by the Watch What Happens Live clubhouse for a night of gossip, games and pondering the prospect of dating Taylor Swift. Grease: Live star Aaron Tveit and Misery headliner Laurie Metcalf were two peas in a pod on January 21 as they chatted with Andy Cohen. Take a look below and on BravoTV.com to get the buzz on Metcalf’s time with Lindsay Lohan and Madonna, discover Tveit’s takes on James Franco and Blake Lively’s scents and then some. Tell us more, tell us more!