With Hamilton’s big win on February 15, Renée Elise Goldsberry is officially a Grammy winner. Oddly, no one bothered to tell Renée Elise Goldsberry. While visiting Late Night, the Hamilton star confessed that she did not realize that when the show won Best Musical Theater Album, she and her co-stars also received awards. “I’ve been dreaming of winning a Grammy since Whitney Houston was winning Grammys,” she said. Now, whether she knew it at the time or not, her dream came true. Check out the clips below to discover Goldsberry’s initial reaction to hearing Angelica Schuyler’s show-stopper, “Satisfied” (hint: it involves a lot of four-letter words), why she made a stranger take a selfie with her after the BET Awards and more.