Good morning, good day! Audiences have been falling head over heels for She Loves Me since its March 17 opening—but don’t ask leading lovers Laura Benanti and Zachary Levi to quote the reviews. The rom-com revival’s stars stopped by The Today Show on March 22 to reveal why they don’t read them—and indulged in some vanilla ice cream of course! “If they’re bad, you have to go out and be like ‘I’m terrible!’” Benanti said. “If they’re great, then you’re like ‘What’s that thing that made me great?’ It just makes you self-conscious.” Her character Amalia spends enough time wondering “Will He Like Me?” onstage. Luckily, Benanti, Levi and the rest of the cast like each other very much. She Loves Me is currently running at Studio 54. Treat yourself to watching the adorable sit-down below!