The Ten Commandments features a score by Patrick Leonard, lyrics by Maribeth Derry and direction by Robert Iscove. It began performances at the Kodak Theatre on September 18 and opened to mostly harsh reviews on September 27. Charles Isherwood of The New York Times wrote: "This bland, static, overproduced and underdirected musical all but submerges the famous episodes from Moses' life in an oily sea of pleasant but unremarkable pop music."
In addition to Kilmer, the tuner features Kevin Earley, Lauren Kennedy, Aharon Ipalé, Adam Lambert, Alisan Porter, Nita Whitaker, Luba Mason, Michele Pereira and Nick Rodriguez.