The complete L.A. cast, who are reprising their roles in the original Broadway company and the show's off-Broadway run at Second Stage, is as follows: Derrick Baskin as Mitch Mahoney, Deborah S. Craig as Marcy Park, Jesse Tyler Ferguson as Leaf Coneybear, Dan Fogler as William Barfee, Lisa Howard as Rona Lisa Peretti, Celia Keenan-Bolger as Olive Ostrovsky, Jose Llana as Chip Tolentino, Jay Reiss as Douglas Panch and Sarah Saltzberg as Logainne Schwartzandgrubenierre.
In order to allow for the Los Angeles reunion, a new company will take over at Broadway's Circle in the Square Theatre on April 17, headed up by The Daily Show's Mo Rocca as Principal Panch. Jared Gertner will stay on in the role of William Barfee and the company will also welcome Aaron J. Albano as Chip Tolentino, Stanley Bahorek as Leaf Coneybear, Jenni Barber as Olive Ostrovsky, Sara Inbar as Logainne Schwartzandgrubiennaire, James Monroe Iglehart as Mitch Mahoney, Greta Lee as Marcy Park and Jennifer Simard as Rona Lisa Perretti.