Carpinello's understudy, Andre Ward, who usually plays muse Terpsicore among other roles in the show, performed the role for the June 12 evening performance of Xanadu and will continue in the part until further notice. Curtis Holbrook, who notably appeared in All Shook Up on Broadway, is another understudy for the part, but he also appears in the substantial dancing role of Young Danny in the show.
Carpinello is best known for originating the role of Tony Manero in the 1999 musical version of Saturday Night Fever, a performance which earned him an Outer Critics Circle Award nomination. Off-Broadway, he played a teen hunk in the comedy Stupid Kids at the WPA Theatre and the Century Center for the Performing Arts. Carpinello was cast—and started rehearsals—as Link Larkin in the original cast of Hairspray but dropped out of the project to take a role in the war film The Great Raid. He has also been seen in the film The Punisher and in the TV shows Felicity, So noTORIous and The Closer.