Caulfield most recently appeared on the New York stage in Manhattan Theatre Club's production of Charles Busch's Our Leading Lady. Other notable New York theater credits include Tryst, My Night with Reg, My Deah, An Inspector Calls, Salonika, Entertaining Mr. Sloane, Paradise Lost and Class Enemy, His notable film credits include The Real Blonde, Grease II and The Boys Next Door, in addition to his long run as Miles Colby on the TV soap Dynasty.
McCarthy most recently appeared on Broadway as Chieftain Dubhdara in The Pirate Queen. His other Broadway credits include Urinetown, Side Show, Beauty and the Beast, Smile, Zorba and The Pirates of Penzance.
As of November 19, the Broadway production of Chicago stars Michelle DeJean as Roxie Hart, Brenda Braxton as Velma Kelly, Vincent Pastore as Amos Hart, Aida Turturro as Matron "Mama" Morton and R. Lowe as Mary Sunshine.