Three-time Tony Award nominee Andy Karl currently stars in the dual roles of 'Pastor Bill O'Keefe' and 'Dr. Godfrey' in the hit musical Teeth, Michael R. Jackson and Anna K. Jacobs' stage adaptation of the 2007 cult horror film. He previously returned to Groundhog Day in the critically acclaimed reprisals at London’s Old Vic and Melbourne’s Princess Theatre as ‘Phil Connors,’ the role he originated on Broadway which won him an Olivier Award, a Drama Desk Award, and a Tony Nomination. Andy was previously seen in the Broadway revival of Into the Woods as both Rapunzel’s Prince and Cinderella’s Prince/The Wolf, and leading the Broadway musical Pretty Woman as Edward Lewis. In television, Andy is well known for his 1-year stint on Law & Order: Special Victims Unit as Lieutenant Mike Dodds. He recurred on ABC’s Forever and has appeared on The Good Fight, Blue Bloods, and Prodigal Son. Additional film credits include starring opposite Michael Douglas and Diane Keaton in the feature film And So It Goes, directed by Rob Reiner, Here After opposite Christina Ricci, Joyful Noise, and New York, I Love You. Other notable theater credits include the Broadway revival of On the Twentieth Century, the title role in Rocky, The Mystery of Edwin Drood, 9 to 5, Legally Blonde, The Wedding Singer, Saturday Night Fever, and Tommy. He has performed in concerts at Carnegie Hall, Lincoln Center, and the San Francisco Symphony.